Skip to contentNew Year offer₹4,999 ₹2,999Ends 1 Jan
All posts

5 min read

COD vs Prepaid Orders: Costs, Risks and How to Shift the Mix

Cash on delivery vs prepaid orders for Indian online sellers: what COD really costs, where the risks are, and practical ways to move more buyers to prepaid.

Cash on delivery is the reason many Indian shoppers are willing to buy from a brand they have never heard of. It removes the fear of paying for something that never arrives. But for the seller, a COD order is a promise, not a sale. Until the cash is collected and remitted to you, the order can still turn into a refusal, an RTO and a loss.

Most sellers can't switch COD off entirely without losing orders. The better goal is to understand what each COD order really costs you and then nudge more buyers towards prepaid. This guide shows how.

What a COD order actually costs

The visible cost is the COD fee your courier or shipping aggregator charges, usually a fixed amount or a percentage of the order value, whichever is higher. Check your current rate card, because it varies by partner and plan. But the bigger costs are less visible:

  • RTO shipping. When a COD buyer refuses the parcel, you usually pay forward shipping and return shipping, and get nothing.
  • Blocked stock. The product is out of your warehouse for one to two weeks on a failed order, which hurts during a sale.
  • Damage on return. RTO parcels travel twice and sometimes come back crushed or opened.
  • Slower cash. COD money is collected by the courier and remitted to you on a cycle, so your cash arrives later than with prepaid.
  • Team time. Confirmation calls, NDR follow-ups and RTO reconciliation all take hours.

An illustrative example

Say you sell a ₹999 product on your own website. Forward shipping is ₹70, the COD fee is ₹40 and return shipping on an RTO is another ₹70. If one in five COD orders is refused, the RTO cost of those failed orders is spread across the ones that succeed:

Prepaid order COD order
Forward shipping ₹70 ₹70
COD fee ₹0 ₹40
Share of RTO cost (1 in 5 fails, ₹140 each) ₹0 ₹35
Approximate fulfilment cost per delivered order ₹70 ₹145

These numbers are only an example, but the pattern holds for most sellers: a delivered COD order can cost close to double a prepaid one once refusals are counted. Run the same table with your own rates and RTO percentage.

Marketplaces vs your own website

On Amazon, Flipkart and Meesho, the marketplace decides payment options for the buyer, collects the money and handles COD logistics. You still feel COD through RTO and returns, but you can't offer your own prepaid discount the way you can on a website. Your levers there are listing accuracy, fast dispatch and good packaging, which we cover in our guide to reducing RTO and returns.

On your own D2C website, you control the checkout, so most of the ideas below apply there.

How to shift the mix towards prepaid

1. Give a reason to pay now

A small, clear benefit at checkout works better than a vague message.

  • Free shipping on prepaid orders, with a shipping charge on COD.
  • A modest prepaid discount, for example ₹30 to ₹50 on a ₹999 order, if your margin allows.
  • A small extra, such as a free sample, on prepaid orders.

Work out the maths first. If a COD order costs you about ₹75 more, offering ₹40 off prepaid still leaves you better off.

2. Add a COD fee or a minimum

Some stores add a small COD handling charge or set a minimum order value for COD. Be transparent about it and show it before the final step, not as a surprise. Test it on a portion of traffic first, because it can reduce total orders.

3. Try partial COD on high-value orders

Ask for a small advance online (say ₹99 or ₹199) and collect the rest on delivery. A buyer who has paid something is far less likely to refuse. Check whether your payment gateway and checkout support this.

4. Build trust at checkout

Buyers choose COD because they don't trust the store yet. Reduce that doubt:

  • Show your returns and refund policy clearly.
  • Display contact details, a WhatsApp number and a registered business name.
  • Show secure payment logos and genuine customer reviews.
  • Offer familiar payment options: UPI, cards, net banking and wallets.

UPI has made prepaid much easier for Indian buyers, so make sure UPI is fast and prominent on mobile.

5. Confirm COD orders before dispatch

Send an automated WhatsApp or SMS asking the buyer to confirm the order, and call on high-value orders. Unconfirmed orders can be held for a day before dispatch. Many stores also offer a "convert to prepaid" link in that confirmation message.

6. Limit COD where it doesn't work

Use your own data. If certain pincodes, product types or order values have very high refusal rates, you can disable COD for those, or allow prepaid only. Your shipping aggregator usually shows RTO by pincode. If you are still choosing a courier setup, our guide to shipping aggregators for D2C websites explains what to look for.

Don't kill COD completely

For many categories and smaller towns, a large share of buyers still want COD. Turning it off can cut your orders more than it saves on RTO. The aim is a healthier mix, not zero COD. Track three numbers monthly:

  1. Prepaid share of orders
  2. COD refusal (RTO) rate
  3. Fulfilment cost per delivered order

If prepaid share rises and RTO falls without total orders dropping, your changes are working.

How Deuxen can help

Deuxen builds and manages Shopify and custom stores with checkout, payment and COD settings that favour prepaid orders without hurting conversion. On marketplaces, our account managers work on the listing, dispatch and returns side that drives RTO.

See our website development service.

Ready to grow your online business?

Tell us about your business and marketplaces. We'll suggest the right plan for you.

  • No lock-in
  • Up to 100 SKUs
  • Reply in 2 working hours